DisclosureLens
All incidentsView linkage analytics →Get the evidence package — $79what’s inside →
Leak SiteHHS OCRState AGConfirmed78 filings · 11 statesLifecycle stage 2 of 3: ConfirmedUnverified claimConfirmedEnforcedcl0phigh sensitivity
Merged incident · 78 filings

Pension Benefit Information, LLC — May 2023 breach

Clustered 78 filings across 12 jurisdictions · filing window Jun 26, 2023 → Mar 22, 2024. View entity profile → Other incidents for this victim →

⚠ 2 cross-filing discrepancies →Merge100%

Determination

Confirmed

Members

78 filings

States

11

Affected · reported

2,373,076

First → last filing

Jun 26, 2023 → Mar 22, 2024

Merge confidence

100%

incident inc_e1feff6bc203429b · merged by human · confidence 100%

Part of the Progress Software Corporation supply-chain incident (2023) — at least 97 organizations filed notifications naming this third party.
Confirmed breach. Merged as one breach: 77 regulatory filings and 1 unverified claim. The filings describe hacking. Intrusion May 29, 2023–May 30, 2023, discovered May 31, 2023 — the first regulatory filing landed 26 days later (flagged late). 2,373,076 individuals reported across the linked filings. Data reported: Government ID, Identity (basic), PII, and 3 more. Notifications rolled out on a 270-day schedule across 77 filings beginning Jun 26, 2023. Each member filing remains the legal record for its jurisdiction.

Litigation Timing

Supplemental
Notification delay
26days

Discovered → first regulatory filing

Discovery variance
54days

Range of discovered_at dates across filings

Leak precedence
Noneclaim trailed by 30d

Days between the first leak-site claim and the first regulatory filing. Positive = the claim came first (public exposure before disclosure). Negative = the claim trailed the filing, so there was no pre-disclosure leak. Counts regulatory filings only — press coverage is not a regulatory disclosure.

Filing span
270days

Time between earliest and latest filing

Not recorded for this incident

Materiality delta · SEC filing delay — no SEC 8-K in this cluster.

Regulatory clocksVermont✗ VT AG >45 bdayLeak gap✗ Leak >180dCalifornia✗ CA 60-day late · 79dMaine⏱ ME AG >30d · 39dWashington⏱ WA AG >30dHawaii✓ HI CRA notice dueOregon✓ OR AG ≤45dHIPAA✓ HHS notifiedFull clock table in Litigation Timeline

Sensitive data

identity_government

Incident timeline

May 29, 2023breach begins
May 31, 2023discovered · members disagree
notification delay · 26 days
Jun 26, 2023first filing
Mar 22, 2024most recent filing

Dashed segments are unestablished, not zero — they fill in as filings merge into this incident.

Member cascade — every filing about this breach

  1. JUN 26HI AGHI AG noticefirst filing · 1,802 HI residentsday 0
  2. JUL 10DE AGDE AG notice1,604 DE residents+14d
  3. JUL 10MT AGMT AG notice891 MT residents+14d
  4. JUL 11CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+15d
  5. JUL 11ME AGME AG noticestates nationwide total 371,359+15d
  6. JUL 12VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+16d
  7. JUL 12OR AGOR AG noticestates nationwide total 371,359+16d
  8. JUL 12DE AGDE AG notice1,604 DE residents+16d
  9. JUL 12WA AGWA AG notice18,856 WA residents+16d
  10. JUL 14NH AGNH AG noticeno count stated+18d
  11. JUL 14HHS OCRHHS OCR noticestates nationwide total 1,866,694+18d
  12. JUL 16DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+20d
  13. JUL 17CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+21d
  14. JUL 17CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+21d
  15. JUL 17NH AGNH AG notice2,114 NH residents+21d
  16. JUL 17DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+21d
  17. JUL 19DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+23d
  18. JUL 19VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+23d
  19. JUL 21ID AGID AG notice8,051 ID residents+25d
  20. JUL 21MT AGMT AG notice262 MT residents+25d
  21. JUL 25CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+29d
  22. JUL 25HI AGHI AG notice2,250 HI residents+29d
  23. JUL 26Leak sitecl0p postattacker claim · unverified+30d
  24. JUL 27OR AGOR AG noticestates nationwide total 2,373,076+31d
  25. JUL 28CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+32d
  26. JUL 28HI AGHI AG notice6,669 HI residents+32d
  27. JUL 28DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+32d
  28. JUL 31OR AGOR AG noticestates nationwide total 27,946+35d
  29. AUG 2OR AGOR AG noticestates nationwide total 42,922+37d
  30. AUG 3CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+38d
  31. AUG 3VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+38d
  32. AUG 4VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+39d
  33. AUG 4CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+39d
  34. AUG 4ME AGME AG noticestates nationwide total 82,955+39d
  35. AUG 4NH AGNH AG notice91 NH residents+39d
  36. AUG 4CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+39d
  37. AUG 8HI AGHI AG noticeno count stated+43d
  38. AUG 9VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+44d
  39. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  40. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  41. AUG 10CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+45d
  42. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  43. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  44. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  45. AUG 10VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+45d
  46. AUG 11NH AGNH AG notice5 NH residents+46d
  47. AUG 11DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+46d
  48. AUG 11ID AGID AG notice2 ID residents+46d
  49. AUG 16ME AGME AG noticestates nationwide total 9,618+51d
  50. AUG 16VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+51d
  51. AUG 16CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+51d
  52. AUG 16CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+51d
  53. AUG 16DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+51d
  54. AUG 17CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+52d
  55. AUG 18VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+53d
  56. AUG 23VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+58d
  57. AUG 23DE AGDE AG noticeno count stated+58d
  58. AUG 24ME AGME AG noticestates nationwide total 336,672+59d
  59. AUG 24VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+59d
  60. AUG 24CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+59d
  61. AUG 24NH AGNH AG notice1,318 NH residents+59d
  62. AUG 24VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+59d
  63. AUG 24CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+59d
  64. AUG 24CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+59d
  65. AUG 24CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+59d
  66. AUG 24NH AGNH AG notice1,058 NH residents+59d
  67. AUG 25VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+60d
  68. AUG 31CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+66d
  69. SEP 1CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+67d
  70. SEP 15CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+81d
  71. SEP 18CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+84d
  72. SEP 19CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+85d
  73. SEP 22NH AGNH AG notice80 NH residents+88d
  74. SEP 25CA AGCA AG noticeno count stated+91d
  75. SEP 26NH AGNH AG noticeno count stated+92d
  76. SEP 28NH AGNH AG notice4 NH residents+94d
  77. MAR 22VT AGVT AG noticeno count stated+270d
  78. MAR 22NH AGNH AG noticemost recent · 15 NH residents+270d
  79. Watching for additional filings — new sources merge into this incident automatically.

Roll-up facts — reconciled across members

Breach window
May 29, 2023 – May 30, 2023
HI AG
Discovered
May 31, 2023HI AG + MT AG + CA AG +3Jun 2, 2023DE AG + ME AG + OR AG +3Jun 4, 2023ME AGJun 7, 2023DE AGJun 9, 2023ID AGJun 16, 2023ID AGJun 28, 2023OR AGJul 24, 2023NH AGfilings disagree on discovery
Data types
Financial account · Health (basic) · Identity (basic) · Government ID · PHI · PII
HI AG + DE AG + MT AG +7
Attack vector
Third-Party / Supply Chain
HI AG

Each fact cites the member filing that establishes it; when filings conflict, every value shows with its source.

Count reconciliation

per-state reported counts

Nationwide (stated in a filing)

2,373,076

Sum of filed state slices

40,097· 1.7% of stated

98% of the stated total lives in states whose filings carry no count — the dashed share shrinks as filings land.

US2,373,076
WA18,856
ID8,051
HI6,669
NH2,114
ME1,912
DE1,604
MT891

State AGs report only their own residents; teal bars show each state's reported slice. The gray US row is the nationwide total reported in a linked filing.

Evidence ladder — rungs this incident occupies

Leak-site claim1 member

Attacker assertion only. Establishes: claim date, group, alleged victim.

Press / market report

No press coverage linked yet.

State AG / regulator filing77 members

Unlocks: discovery date, data types, affected count, compliance clock.

SEC 8-K / victim statement

No SEC filing or victim statement yet.

Merge provenance

Method
human
Confidence
1.00 · above the 0.85 auto-merge floor
Reviewed
operator-reviewed Aug 10, 2026 · at least one link edge was human-adjudicated
Audit
Every link edge records its method, confidence and model + prompt versions (100% is the strongest edge).

Merges are reversible — a wrong link can be detached with its audit trail intact. How merging works.

Filing velocity

Spread

270 days

Cadence

~1 / 3.5d

vs. multi-state median

33.8× slower

About this clustering

DisclosureLens links filings into incidents through layered matchers: deterministic rules (same source document, multistate filings of one breach, tight-window same-victim pairs), a weighted-similarity scorer for cross-source candidates, and an operator review queue for everything uncertain. Each link records its own method and confidence — shown per filing in the timeline below. The system defaults to NOT merging when uncertain, because a false merge (collapsing two unrelated breaches) is more harmful than a false split (showing related filings separately); uncertain pairs route to human review instead of auto-merging. This page states only what the linked filings agree on; each filing's own account stays on its own record, linked from the timeline below.

The weekly clock on records like this one

The Disclosure Clock is a weekly briefing on what landed in the disclosure record, and the gap between the criminals' post and the regulator's filing — measured on the whole record, with the method shown.

Weekly. Double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe, and the address goes nowhere else.